The American dream: a look at Allen & Overy's potential US presence post-merger

25 September 2023
Allen & Overy current Partner headcount
Allen & Overy post-merger Partner headcount

Allen & Overy and Shearman & Sterling are due to begin their Partner votes on the proposed merger at the end of September. If approved, the merger will create a mega firm of almost 4,000 attorneys worldwide. Given that the deal would represent a major milestone for a UK firm securing a foothold in the US market, we decided to have a look at what Allen & Overy's presence in the United States could look like if the merger goes ahead.


Magic Circle firms have been growing their US Partner numbers over the last few years. Some faster than others.

Line graph showing US partner headcount growth of Magic Circle firms from August 2021 to August 2023.

Using data from Pirical Legal Professionals we dug into the current headcount of US based Magic Circle Partners and mapped out the potential Partner headcount of A&O Shearman, comparing their improved regional presence to their British rivals.


The figures are based on all current Shearman & Sterling US Partners staying post-merger. However, even if 50% of Shearman's Partners leave between now and the completion of the merger, A&O Shearman will still be the largest Magic Circle firm in the US with around 150 combined Partners.


For context, Shearman & Sterling's Partner attrition rate in the United States over the last 12 months has been 15%.

Bar graph comparing US partner headcount for Magic Circle firms and Shearman & Sterling. Data as of August 2023.

New York City

The four Magic Circle firms with a US presence (Clifford Chance, Allen & Overy, Linklaters, and Freshfields) all have their largest offices in New York City. Between them they currently have almost 200 Partners based in NYC, with Clifford Chance leading the pack in terms of headcount.

Map: Partner headcount of Magic Circle firms in NYC, with colored circles representing firms.

Should the merger go ahead, Allen & Overy will overtake their British rival and substantially increase their headcount to well over 100 New York Partners.

Map showing potential Allen & Overy locations on the East Coast with Shearman & Sterling merger approval.

Washington, DC

It's likely to be a similar story in Washington, DC where Allen & Overy could increase their headcount from 19 to over 30 Partners, compared to Clifford Chance (23 Partners), Freshfields (17 Partners), and Linklaters (7 Partners).

Texas

Thanks to Shearman & Sterling's 3 offices in Texas, Allen & Overy will gain a new regional presence in the US.


Texas has been a real growth spot among the AM Law 100 over the last few years and Clifford Chance's recent opening of a Houston office (9 Partners) highlights the desire for Magic Circle firms to get in on the action. Allen & Overy's new foothold in the state is likely to overshadow Clifford Chance's presence and given that competition for Texan talent will be tough, gaining Shearman's offices in Houston, Dallas, and Austin could prove to be a huge win for A&O.

Map showing potential Allen & Overy presence in Texas post-merger, with offices in Austin, Dallas, and Houston.

California

Allen & Overy and Freshfields are the two Magic Circle firms to have expanded into the Californian market, with both firms opening offices in Silicon Valley in the last few years. Freshfield's 14 Partners currently outweigh Allen & Overy's 8, but should the merger go ahead A&O Shearman would double their Partner numbers in the Bay Area.


Allen & Overy already have a strong presence in California with 6 Partners also in Los Angeles. The addition of Shearman & Sterling's Bay Area based Partners would comfortably give the new firm a clear lead in California as a whole.

Map of California showing Allen & Overy's potential presence after the merger. Green dot: Bay Area, Grey dot: Los Angeles.

Interested in legal market insights?


Understand the market better and dive into competitor insights with our legal market intelligence tools. Make decisions based on data with our comprehensive market coverage; monitor which law firms are thriving and which are churning, track attorney movements, and identify trends within the legal industry.

Book a free demo

Subscribe to the latest data insights & blog updates



Fresh, original content for Law Firms and Legal Recruiters interested in data, diversity & inclusion, legal market insights, recruitment, and legal practice management.

Get updates via email
Bar chart showing percentage headcount change in PE practices from Jan 2021 to Jan 2022 across eight global law firms.
by Craig Savitzky 14 April 2026
Pirical data tracking 50,000+ lawyers across PE and capital markets practices reveals a three-year talent reshaping more dramatic than the numbers indicate.
A table listing the top 14 Law Firms in the AM Law 101-200 by growth in Partner headcount
by Emily Turner 9 April 2026
See Pirical's Ranking of Which AM Law 101-200 Law Firms Have Seen the Most Significant Growth in the Past Year
A line graph titled
8 April 2026
Pirical has been working with customers to diagnose their current state of productivity and to test ideas about what really drives productivity across the market.
by Lakshana Susinthiran 7 April 2026
Lateral Partner retention is a vital metric for law firms. "Each year, law firms invest countless hours, money, and resources in their lateral hiring efforts" , so the success rate of each lateral hire has significant implications to any firm. Based on input from a number of firms, a key window for a lateral Partner hire is the first 3 years from joining. Within that timeframe, most firms will have a sense of whether the hire is going to be a success, or not! Using publicly-available data tracked by Pirical , we've analyzed how many of the lateral Partner hires made by AM Law 100 firms between 2020-2022 exited the firm within 3 years of joining.
Chart of top 50 lateral hiring over time, increasing trend from Jan 2023 to Jan 2026. Green bars.
by Emily Turner 31 March 2026
The Volume of Lateral Moves From AM Law 1-50 to 101-150 Firms has Increased by +45% Over the Last 3 Years.
Table showing a list of names with corresponding numbers in two columns labeled
by Craig Savitzky 10 March 2026
Which law firms had already positioned themselves years earlier to capture what may become the largest energy legal market since post-invasion Iraq?