How legal recruiters can be more valuable to clients - by challenging them

8 August 2019

In this week’s instalment of the Pirical Podcast, we talk to Edward Parker , Director at Fides Search , a Legal, Regulatory and Compliance Hires Consultancy and Recruitment Firm. 

Fides’s point of differentiation is that they work globally and that they look to execute more than just a client’s search request. Instead, they always take a step back and boil a search request down to first principles, asking what the client really wants to accomplish. 

Contents:

0:00 - 1:20 Introduction, Background to Fides Search

1:20 - 2:40 New Approaches to sourcing: Data & Intelligence

2:40 - 4:30 Example of applying data to a search

4:30 - 6:00 Going beyond the brief of a search - crunch the data beforehand

6:00 - 7:40 Other agencies copying the Fides approach - imitation being the sincerest form of flattery

7:40 - 9:10 Data has made a big difference, but not single-handedly delivered the result. 

9:10 - 12:35 Example: How data has helped with key insights about long-term lawyer success; Challenging clients with a fixed binary view.

12:35 - 16:00 Teasing out from clients what they really want through intelligent questioning

16:00 - 19:00 Good questioning can save the client money by not hiring partners

19:00 - 20:50 On politely pushing back to clients and keeping open, honest relationships

20:50 - 22:45 Working with Pirical

22:45 - end On recruiters being data-fluent, wrap-up, more about Fides Search

Pushing back to move forward

Often, a client’s wish list for an ideal candidate is very large, and some trade-offs will be inevitable. In our interview, starting at 10:45, Edward mentions the case of a challenging senior hire in a specialist area. Most clients look at the candidate’s billing history, usually at the last three years. 

However, Edward and his team learned from the data at their disposal, that in highly specialised areas, it’s not important what a person’s historic billing rates have been. It’s more important what do they know, what they’ve specialised in and what’s their reputation. As a result, Fides Search have successfully placed great candidates from in-house positions (without a billing track record).

“Sometimes if a client has a very fixed view and we believe it’s not executable, part of our job is to use the data and experience we have to try to open them up to other ideas and different ways to realise the outcome.”

This kind of gentle pushback on the client’s priorities is in high demand. A trusted partner in people search needs to be on par with the client. They cannot be expected to agree with everything the client says but instead need to help course-correct a client and suggest a different path. As Edward says: “Sometimes if a client has a very fixed view and we believe it’s not executable, part of our job is to use the data and experience we have to try to open them up to other ideas and different ways to realise the outcome.” 

Data has been crucial in this type of course-correction work for Fides Search. Understanding the existing competitor landscape, for example, helps manage a client’s expectations as to what kind of hires they will be able to get. Some clients who don’t have the name recognition of the largest law firms need to be aware of their employer brand and what is possible to make happen with it. This conversation can be difficult to be had, but using data can make it easier. 


Questioning with data can also save the client money

For example, when a client is set on getting a new hire at partner level, a good search consultant can suggest to find another way: If the firm has a 3-5 year time horizon with that hire, why not hire at a pre-partner level (which will cost significantly less) and develop that hire to partner level. 

That, of course, will be to the detriment of your own revenue. But of course, any search firm worth its salt will disregard this fact, fully knowing that a short-term hit like that will be more than offset in the long run. “We pride ourselves with getting the best possible outcome for our clients”, says Edward, adding diplomatically:  “It’s not a given that that’s how our industry works.”

We hope you enjoy listening to the entire interview. 






Subscribe to the latest data insights & blog updates



Fresh, original content for Law Firms and Legal Recruiters interested in data, diversity & inclusion, legal market insights, recruitment, and legal practice management.

Get updates via email
A green map of the united kingdom on a white background.
11 June 2025
London dominates much of the UK's legal landscape but other legal hubs play a significant role and some are even growing at a faster rate. We've taken a closer look at the current distribution of the UK's top lawyers, which markets have been growing the fastest, and how large a presence US firms now have in the UK. Using publicly-available data tracked by Pirical Legal Professionals (PLP) , here's a snapshot of the UK legal market in 2025.
Photo from Pirical Pioneers 2025
20 May 2025
Last week, Pirical celebrated a decade of innovation at our biggest Pirical Pioneers event to date! We brought together a fantastic crowd of Recruitment, Strategy, HR & DEI leaders for some insightful panel discussions and previews of our latest tools & new features.
McDermott's office growth post-merger
9 May 2025
Yesterday, McDermott Will & Emery and Schulte Roth & Zabel announced their plans to merge. The combination would create a law firm of around 1,600 attorneys and $2.8 billion of revenue. The merged firm would rank in the top 20 of the AM Law 100. If approved, the merger would unite McDermott's broad expertise in healthcare, dispute resolution, and corporate law with Schulte's deep focus on hedge funds, private capital, and financial regulation. This latest announcement follows in the footsteps of other recent combinations like Herbert Smith Freehills & Kramer Levin and Troutman Pepper & Locke Lord . Using publicly-available data tracked by Pirical Legal Professionals (PLP) , we've taken a look at which locations & practices would grow under the merger.
US attorney headcount by city
6 May 2025
Which US states and cities have the highest number of attorneys, which practice areas are the most prominent and which firms are leading the market with the highest Partner headcount
Lateral Partner demand in certain practices shifted across different segments of the AM Law 200
30 January 2025
Using publicly-available data from Pirical Legal Professionals (PLP), we've taken a look at the lateral Partner hires and headcount growth from 2024 to see which law firms and practices had the most interesting growth stories of the year.
Change in size of Partner promotions class
12 December 2024
As we near the end of the year, there have been a flurry of Partner promotion announcements from the top AM Law firms. Overall, the promotion class sizes have decreased for the second year in a row.
More posts